Wailing Wing Sauce

This week, spice lovers, we take another look at the first of my Screaming Chimp Samples and I figure, why not start with the basics? Their original sauce. The one that got their company going.

2017-03-24 11.46.51

Designed as a hot but usable wing sauce, the makers’ choice of ghost, scorpion and fatalii chillies seems like a bold one.

“Ghost Pepper” and “Trinidad Scorpion” are names that hardly need any explanation these days as even the average person on the street has heard tales of the former’s insane strength by now. They’re plastered on the side of many a challenge-oriented sauce and always boasted about as a selling point.

And the fatalii, while lesser known, is definitely not a novice’s pepper either, having made itself known in the chilli community with a very unique blend of heat that hits well above its habanero-like scoville rating.

So to see them here, talked about like they were some gourmet flavour, is quite a surprise. A pleasant surprise, though, as they do actually bring a lot to the table in that department.

The ghost pepper, as I’m sure you’ve heard me say before, is an interesting all rounder of a chilli, with deep red, fruity and even citrus elements, all balanced such that different sauces can easily bring out different sides of it.

But its not hard to see what side they’re going for here. The scorpion and fatalii are both fruity chillies and so too are the milder (but still far from mild) scotch bonnet and lemon drop. All but the scotch bonnet have citrus notes of some sort and the lemon drop actually tastes very strongly of its namesake fruit.

And, if that wasn’t enough to clue you in, the sauce also contains orange juice, lemon juice and cider vinegar, all of which tend to produce a sharp and fruity flavour.

All that can be gleaned from the finely printed text on the sides of this bottle but the front actually tells us remarkably little.

Screaming Chimp’s branding is, as I mentioned in my introduction to the company, very strong. That three colour chimp logo, front and centre is practically unforgettable and its facial expression sure implies heat. If I were an average shopper who didn’t know they had an entire range marked with it, I’d be expecting a three plus from this one for sure.

And indeed, they have a three chilli rating beneath it, though we have no way of knowing from one bottle what their scale goes up to.

If the chillies they’ve chosen are anything to go by, we could be looking at something well in excess of my scale’s five but, on the other hand, the total pepper content of this sauce is a mere 5.2%. That’s not a high purity at all.

And, of course, being their original sauce, its red-backed name tells us very little. So I guess it’s time to find out what it’s like the old fashioned way.

2017-03-19 12.51.57

As it turns out, what we have here is a stinging heat, presumably from the scorpion and fatalii content, that rather resembles the chocolate habanero sauce I tried in january. It comes in fairly quickly, too, though not before the sauce’s flavour, and its peak strength is also pretty close to that habanero one. A



towards the low end of that number but definitely at the very top of what you might get with the more common habanero varieties.

It’s a good, rather throaty burn that doesn’t overstay its welcome or hit like a superhot product, despite technically being one. It’s definitely strong but its not outside the realm of what habanero and scotch bonnet lovers will be able to enjoy.

Most importantly, though, at least as far as I’m concerned, it has none of that floral taste and instead comes in a wonderfully fruity sauce. As I had expected.

What I wasn’t expecting, however, is where that fruitiness comes from.

The orange and lemon are certainly there but the main fruit here is actually the tomatoes. Fresh tomatoes, mashed and simmered down to act as the base of the sauce.

It’s something that we often forget but tomatoes are indeed a fruit and this sauce really makes that apparent. They do genuinely taste like one when prepared in this way.

The chillies that I was expecting to impart that fruity flavour actually don’t do a lot outside of giving this sauce heat, I’m sad to say, but the honey and sugar definitely pull their weight in counteracting the sourness of the more acidic ingredients. In doing so, they almost give the sauce a sweet and sour taste but its tomato, orange and lemon flavour remains its own unique blend.

If you’re wanting a sauce centred around its hot and fruity chillies, this sauce tries but fails to be that.

If, however, you just want a delicious fruity sauce with a good heat to it, then you definitely won’t be disappointed.

The Screaming Chimp’s Original Hot Sauce is an excellent choice in the flavour department, regardless of how minimally its pepper content comes through, and it would most certainly be at home on chicken wings as the makers suggest.

What I actually see this product doing best at, however, is acting as a cooking sauce to fry up chunks of pork, duck or tofu in a chinese style, perhaps adding noodles, spring onions and a few other vegetables, should you want a full meal out of it.

If this sample was mine to keep, it would be gone pretty quickly but it’s not. I have to return it to the shop it came from so that they can form their own opinions.

10 thoughts on “Wailing Wing Sauce

  1. Niall McKay-Mount April 4, 2017 / 8:15 am

    Thanks for the review. It would have been better from everyone’s point of view, if you had tried all of the sauces before forming opinions on this one and writing a review. It sits in the middle as our are meant to be entry level Chilli Sauces. We also have only been trading for ten months, so if people require more heat from the chillies, we can add more. I only use fresh or frozen, not dried chillies and yes, the sauces are meant to be based on flavour, not heat. There’s a small part of the population that can handle the very hot stuff, but millions love sweet n’heat, which is where we fit in really. Any way. I look forward to your other reviews on the rest of them. Just remember…flavour is king in the Chimp household, otherwise I could have just put pure capcasin oil in some water, with some vinegar and salt and called it a hot sauce, but that just ain’t my style. 🤓


    • Spicefreak April 4, 2017 / 11:56 am

      I have tried them all and had actually done so before writing this review. Any comments I make about expectations going into it are more about demonstrating what the packaging suggests to me and avoiding referancing products my readers haven’t seen yet, with the former at least being highly pertinant to those who have requested this particular series of reviews.

      At no point did I say that this sauce was too mild. I may have said or given the impression that it was mild compared to other sauces with the same chillies but that is very much the case and more because of how insanely hot the chillies you have chosen to use are. That does not mean it’s a mild sauce. The 4/10 I have given it in heat is actually on the high end, pretty much at the top of “entry level”, as you put it. It simply looks a touch low to a first time reader because nature goes to insane levels these days and my scale is required to reflect that.
      I understand that “hot but usable” is what you want from this sauce and it does that well. I never said it needed more heat at all.

      What this sauce is lacking, in my experience, is the flavour of those chillies. You have an excellent sounding blend of them that I would really have liked to be able to taste but I could not.
      But still, you did not leave me disappointed. The other ingredients provided an excellent fruity taste to the sauce that left me wanting more even without the flavour of the chillies so, while some might call you “hot sauce” rather than “chilli sauce”, I’ll happily just call you delicious.

      With that said, however, I feel as though you underestimate the effort that goes into getting oleoresin to mix into a sauce and how much extra work then goes into keeping it from tasting vile. If you would like to see what I think of extract sauce, though, Look at my reviews for Hell Unleashed and Dave’s Insanity. Those two do what they do well but were far from pleasant to review.


      • Niall April 23, 2017 / 7:14 pm

        Thank you very much for replying and clarifying a few things for me. Sounds like I’ve not too much to worry about with regards to the recipe. I apologise if I sounded off, it’s the very first full review other than our Facebook customer reviews that has been done on any of the sauces. I do like to hear feedback, even if it isn’t positive , as we need to hear everyone’s perspective. How ever, shortly after leaving my comments my wife (Mrs Chimp) pointed out that I had been far to hasty in replying in the manor in which I had, as it was actually a good review. It’s hard being in my first year of business and hoping to hear that it’s ” Just magnificent” and don’t. Like I said before…thank you ever so much for the great review.

        All the best

        Mr Chimp

        Liked by 1 person

  2. DAVID August 5, 2017 / 12:13 am

    Really good review! I am going to add this blog to my list of weekly checks.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s